hololake-platform/docs/adr/0099-cumulative-vault-asset-scope.md

type, id, title, status, date, supersedes

type	id	title	status	date	supersedes
ADR	0099	Cumulative vault asset scope for previews	active	2026-04-29	0074 asset-protocol runtime scoping

Context

ADR-0074 moved the desktop asset protocol away from broad filesystem access and toward runtime vault scoping. The implementation tried to keep only the active vault in scope by calling Tauri's forbid_directory for vault roots that were no longer active.

Tauri's filesystem scope treats forbidden paths as permanent precedence rules: a forbidden path is denied even if it is later allowed again. After a user switched away from a vault and back, image and PDF previews could keep producing 403 Forbidden responses for valid vault files until the app restarted.

Decision

Tolaria accumulates Tauri asset protocol access for vault roots loaded during the current app session and never forbids a previously loaded vault root at runtime.

• sync_vault_asset_scope adds the canonical vault root and requested vault root when they are missing from the runtime asset scope.
• The runtime asset scope remains narrower than global filesystem access because only vault roots that Tolaria has loaded are added.
• Command paths still enforce the active vault boundary through the Rust command layer before reads, writes, external opens, and attachment imports.
• Asset scope revocation is deferred to process exit, because Tauri does not expose a safe runtime unallow operation for directories.

Options considered

• Cumulative runtime vault scope (chosen): keeps previews reliable after vault switches while preserving vault-only access in the current process.
• Continue forbidding previous vaults: appears stricter, but Tauri forbids are not reversible and valid previews fail after switching back.
• Allow all filesystem paths: avoids preview failures but returns to the broad asset protocol access that ADR-0074 intentionally removed.
• Replace convertFileSrc with a custom protocol: could support exact active-vault revocation, but it would be a larger cross-cutting migration for editor images, file previews, and PDF rendering.

Consequences

• Images and PDFs from any vault loaded in the current session can keep rendering after vault switches.
• The app process, not each vault switch, is the revocation boundary for asset URL access.
• Active-vault command validation remains the primary guard for mutations and default-app opens.
• Re-evaluate this if Tauri adds a public runtime unallow operation for asset protocol directories.