{
  "schema": "hololake.web-novel-open-source-donor-assessment/v1",
  "record_id": "HLP-WEBNOVEL-OSS-DONORS-001",
  "state": "PRIMARY_SOURCE_CODE_REVIEW_COMPLETE_IMPLEMENTATION_BOUNDARY_LOCKED",
  "reviewed_at": "2026-08-18",
  "download_route": {
    "relay": "BS-SG-003",
    "relay_role": "SINGAPORE_OVERSEAS_SOURCE_DOWNLOAD_RELAY",
    "local_transport": "DIRECT_SSH_FROM_LOCAL_MACHINE",
    "external_drive_root": "/Volumes/JZAO/HoloLake/development/网文行业开源源码调研-20260818",
    "repositories_are_clean_git_worktrees": true
  },
  "rule": "READ_REAL_SOURCE_AND_EXTRACT_AUDITABLE_ENGINE_PATTERNS_NEVER_REPLACE_FUNCTIONAL_ENGINES_WITH_STATIC_DEMOS",
  "candidates": [
    {
      "name": "Kindling",
      "upstream": "https://github.com/smith-and-web/kindling",
      "commit": "1b83cb28eca84e76282d0aa6838d68b5786ecf5f",
      "branch": "main",
      "observed_license": "MIT",
      "role": "PRIMARY_LOCAL_FIRST_AUTHOR_ENGINE_DONOR",
      "inspected_paths": [
        "src-tauri/src/db/schema.rs",
        "src-tauri/src/commands/crud.rs",
        "src-tauri/src/commands/snapshot.rs",
        "src-tauri/src/commands/export.rs",
        "src-tauri/src/parsers",
        "src/lib/components/ScenePanel.svelte",
        "src/lib/components/BeatView.svelte"
      ],
      "observed_engine": [
        "TAURI_RUST_SQLITE_LOCAL_FIRST_STORAGE",
        "PROJECT_CHAPTER_SCENE_BEAT_HIERARCHY",
        "CHARACTER_LOCATION_REFERENCE_RELATIONS",
        "500MS_DEBOUNCED_SAVE_WITH_UNMOUNT_FLUSH",
        "TRANSACTIONAL_REORDER_AND_RESTORE",
        "COMPRESSED_PROJECT_SNAPSHOTS",
        "MARKDOWN_DOCX_EPUB_SCRIVENER_IMPORT_EXPORT"
      ],
      "decision": "ADOPT_ARCHITECTURAL_PATTERNS_AND_REIMPLEMENT_HOLOLAKE_ACCOUNT_SCOPED_ENGINE"
    },
    {
      "name": "novelWriter",
      "upstream": "https://github.com/vkbo/novelWriter",
      "commit": "416078506bbd690c5ad2bf736ec363ed2c0db89c",
      "branch": "main",
      "observed_license": "GPL-3.0-or-later_WITH_ADDITIONAL_ASSET_LICENSES",
      "role": "MATURE_AUTHOR_WORKFLOW_REFERENCE",
      "inspected_paths": [
        "novelwriter/core/storage.py",
        "novelwriter/core/document.py",
        "novelwriter/core/tree.py",
        "novelwriter/core/index.py",
        "novelwriter/core/sessions.py",
        "novelwriter/manuscript"
      ],
      "observed_engine": [
        "HUMAN_READABLE_PROJECT_STORAGE",
        "HANDLE_BASED_PROJECT_TREE",
        "INDEXED_TAGS_REFERENCES_AND_BACK_REFERENCES",
        "FILTERED_MANUSCRIPT_BUILDS",
        "WRITING_SESSION_WORD_AND_TIME_STATISTICS"
      ],
      "decision": "STUDY_CONCEPTS_ONLY_DO_NOT_COPY_GPL_SOURCE"
    },
    {
      "name": "Manuskript",
      "upstream": "https://github.com/olivierkes/manuskript",
      "commit": "7abdba31abbd97bfdd80e72786fe2191d7f42d4a",
      "branch": "develop",
      "observed_license": "GPL-3.0",
      "role": "PLANNING_AND_STORY_BIBLE_REFERENCE",
      "inspected_paths": [
        "manuskript/models/outlineItem.py",
        "manuskript/models/characterModel.py",
        "manuskript/models/worldModel.py",
        "manuskript/load_save/version_1.py",
        "manuskript/exporter"
      ],
      "observed_engine": [
        "NESTED_OUTLINE_WITH_COMPILE_FLAGS",
        "CHARACTER_WORLD_AND_PLOT_MODELS",
        "TEXT_REVISIONS_ON_CHANGE",
        "RECURSIVE_WORD_TARGET_AGGREGATION",
        "SPLIT_MERGE_AND_MULTI_FORMAT_EXPORT"
      ],
      "decision": "STUDY_CONCEPTS_ONLY_DO_NOT_COPY_GPL_SOURCE"
    },
    {
      "name": "novel-plus",
      "upstream": "https://github.com/201206030/novel-plus",
      "commit": "d9f3f464a6bac1f59652955d0901f05438010190",
      "branch": "develop_xxy",
      "observed_license": "Apache-2.0",
      "role": "PRIMARY_CHINESE_WEB_NOVEL_EDITORIAL_AND_OPERATIONS_DONOR",
      "inspected_paths": [
        "novel-front/src/main/java/com/java2nb/novel/controller/AuthorController.java",
        "novel-front/src/main/java/com/java2nb/novel/service/impl/BookServiceImpl.java",
        "novel-admin/src/main/java/com/java2nb/novel/controller",
        "novel-common/src/main/java/com/java2nb/novel/entity",
        "doc/sql/novel_plus.sql"
      ],
      "observed_engine": [
        "AUTHOR_AND_PEN_NAME_IDENTITY",
        "AUTHOR_OWNERSHIP_CHECKS_BEFORE_MUTATION",
        "BOOK_CHAPTER_CONTENT_SEPARATION",
        "ATOMIC_CHAPTER_WORD_COUNT_AND_LATEST_CHAPTER_UPDATES",
        "BOOK_AND_COMMENT_REVIEW_STATUSES",
        "RECOMMENDATION_SLOTS_RANKING_READING_HISTORY_AND_SUBSCRIPTIONS",
        "DAILY_AND_MONTHLY_AUTHOR_INCOME_STATISTICS"
      ],
      "decision": "ADOPT_DOMAIN_AND_TRANSACTION_PATTERNS_WITHOUT_IMPORTING_THE_SERVER_APPLICATION"
    },
    {
      "name": "Editoria",
      "upstream": "https://github.com/Coko-Foundation/editoria",
      "commit": "d22b40bda3dd6519e45a56fe1b3bafaa339832b5",
      "branch": "main",
      "observed_license": "MIT",
      "role": "EDITORIAL_TEAM_AND_PRODUCTION_WORKFLOW_REFERENCE",
      "inspected_paths": [
        "app/components/bookbuilder/src/queries/getBook.js",
        "app/components/bookbuilder/src/queries/getBookTeams.js",
        "app/components/bookbuilder/src/queries/updateTeam.js",
        "app/components/bookbuilder/src/queries/updateWorkflowState.js",
        "app/components/bookbuilder/src/queries/unlockBookComponent.js",
        "app/components/bookbuilder/src/ConnectedBookBuilder.js"
      ],
      "observed_engine": [
        "BOOK_COMPONENT_WORKFLOW_STAGES",
        "OBJECT_SCOPED_TEAMS_AND_ROLES",
        "EDIT_LOCKS_AND_ADMIN_UNLOCK",
        "ORDERED_BOOK_DIVISIONS_AND_COMPONENTS",
        "WORD_INGEST_AND_MULTI_FORMAT_EXPORT"
      ],
      "decision": "ADOPT_WORKFLOW_LOCK_AND_ROLE_SEMANTICS_ONLY_REPOSITORY_IS_CLIENT_ONLY_AND_DEPENDS_ON_EXTERNAL_KETIDA_SERVER"
    },
    {
      "name": "Wax ProseMirror",
      "upstream": "https://github.com/Coko-Foundation/wax-prosemirror",
      "commit": "6cc46bfe3aa9e729cdb4e3802ccbd5c8a22f0f56",
      "branch": "master",
      "observed_license": "MIT_WITH_SEPARATE_TRACK_CHANGES_NOTICE",
      "role": "EDITOR_ANNOTATION_AND_TRACK_CHANGES_REFERENCE",
      "inspected_paths": [
        "wax-prosemirror-core/src/utilities/track-changes/trackedTransaction.js",
        "wax-prosemirror-services/src/TrackChangeService",
        "wax-prosemirror-services/src/CommentsService",
        "wax-prosemirror-services/src/YjsService/YjsService.js"
      ],
      "observed_engine": [
        "TRANSACTION_LEVEL_INSERT_DELETE_FORMAT_TRACKING",
        "ACCEPT_AND_REJECT_CHANGE_OPERATIONS",
        "INLINE_COMMENT_MARKS_AND_REPLY_THREADS",
        "OPTIONAL_YJS_COLLABORATION_PROVIDER"
      ],
      "decision": "DEFER_DIRECT_INTEGRATION_REIMPLEMENT_SMALL_LOCAL_REVIEW_MODEL_FIRST_BECAUSE_STACK_AND_PACKAGES_ARE_OLD"
    }
  ],
  "implementation_selection": {
    "direct_external_runtime_packages_added": 0,
    "external_source_files_copied": 0,
    "native_owner": "HOLOLAKE_TAURI_RUST_CORE",
    "storage": "AUTHENTICATED_ACCOUNT_SCOPED_SQLITE",
    "selected_patterns": [
      "PROJECT_VOLUME_CHAPTER_HIERARCHY",
      "DEBOUNCED_CHAPTER_SAVE_WITH_FLUSH",
      "OPTIMISTIC_REVISION_CONFLICTS",
      "CHAPTER_VERSION_HISTORY_AND_PROJECT_CHECKPOINTS",
      "CHARACTER_WORLD_RELATION_AND_FORESHADOW_GRAPH",
      "EDITORIAL_WORKFLOW_STATE_MACHINE_AND_REVIEW_NOTES",
      "CONTINUITY_AUDIT",
      "AUTHORIZED_OPERATIONS_METRICS",
      "MARKDOWN_EXPORT"
    ]
  },
  "legal_boundary": "PRELIMINARY_ENGINEERING_SCREEN_NOT_FINAL_DISTRIBUTION_LEGAL_APPROVAL"
}