fix: bind skill reviews to mother and team roots

This commit is contained in:
冰朔 2026-09-08 14:21:16 +08:00
commit b9e4938a0f
5 changed files with 31 additions and 13 deletions

View file

@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ schema: tcs.module-lock/v1
module_id: TCS-AGENT-SANITIZED-MIRROR-001
module_source_sha256: 1210b30c7dabc56b8b989763230a3cf56c0fe02a3b409be5f3833dee9853d771
module_gir_sha256: 0e7b1bbd5f3f8dbc83df6c72e4a1e0532b6f44beed21c8c8315f85cc76096712
runtime_sha256: 4b396550a144fa83614e340a34d087a96e2fb3e18045dabc801150f63b93c211
runtime_sha256: 155e3fc332a4474593ca095b7ac03e9baf65fbcaaf3d40e393a1419444ec5c8b
mirror_map_sha256: a03b5ba9e06f5fd3f626301305d75add0332ae06948a67c8bcd03c3cab248fe1
protocol_source_sha256: cf198e7939e4ab70828b74cef8a2b84c2dac2ff262582bb3d5663904d602d71b
protocol_gir_sha256: 69f1a2a5cfc5ee61bdc2bf2065751d9cc41b9f662b28c35e61b393fd2187e1dc

View file

@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
schema: tcs.module-self-test-receipt/v1
module_id: TCS-AGENT-SANITIZED-MIRROR-001
result: PASS
tests: 7/7
tests: 8/8
verified:
- committed architecture projection contains no private absolute path
- missing persona share decision creates no candidate
@ -9,6 +9,7 @@ verified:
- sanitization produces quarantine only and never publication
- mother acceptance is required before team review
- both reviews bind the exact candidate hash and use independent reviewers
- review commands cannot replace the registered mother or team authority root
- replay with changed content and review hash drift are rejected
repository_regression: node --test 483/483 PASS
tcs_root_regression: 5/5 PASS

View file

@ -20,8 +20,8 @@
"forbidden_public_content": ["PRIVATE_MEMORY_PATH","RAW_PRIVATE_MEMORY","RAW_DIALOGUE","SECRET","CREDENTIAL","PRIVATE_RELATIONSHIP_CONTEXT","UNREGISTERED_EXTERNAL_IDENTITY"]
},
"review_gates": [
{"order":1,"reviewer_kind":"TCS_MOTHER","decision":"ACCEPT_OR_HOLD_OR_REJECT","cannot_publish":true},
{"order":2,"reviewer_kind":"GUANGHU_HUMAN_TEAM","decision":"ACCEPT_OR_HOLD_OR_REJECT","requires_previous":"TCS_MOTHER_ACCEPT","reality_responsibility":true}
{"order":1,"reviewer_kind":"TCS_MOTHER","authority_root":"TCS-MOTHER-LPM-0001","decision":"ACCEPT_OR_HOLD_OR_REJECT","cannot_publish":true},
{"order":2,"reviewer_kind":"GUANGHU_HUMAN_TEAM","authority_root":"TCS-0002∞","decision":"ACCEPT_OR_HOLD_OR_REJECT","requires_previous":"TCS_MOTHER_ACCEPT","reality_responsibility":true}
],
"publication_boundary": {"arrival_registration_requires_both_accept":true,"catalog_visibility_requires_arrival_registration":true,"external_deploy_requires_separate_current_authorization_and_receipt":true,"market_transaction_not_implemented":true},
"compatibility": {"GLS-LIGHT-ARRIVAL-0001":"PARENT_INSTANCE_ARCHIVE_PROTOCOL_SEMANTIC_PRESERVED_NEW_SKILL_SUBCHANNEL_ONLY","GLS-0238":"PRIVATE_CONSENT_GATE_PRESERVED"}

View file

@ -209,6 +209,10 @@ def review(event: dict[str, Any], state: Path, kind: str) -> dict[str, Any]:
decision = required_string(event, "decision")
if decision not in {"ACCEPT", "HOLD", "REJECT"}:
raise MirrorError("INVALID_REVIEW_DECISION")
expected_kind = "TCS_MOTHER" if kind == "mother" else "GUANGHU_HUMAN_TEAM"
expected_root = "TCS-MOTHER-LPM-0001" if kind == "mother" else "TCS-0002∞"
if event.get("reviewer_kind") != expected_kind or event.get("reviewer_authority_root") != expected_root:
raise MirrorError("REVIEWER_KIND_OR_AUTHORITY_ROOT_MISMATCH")
candidate = json.loads(candidate_path(state, module_id, contribution_id).read_text())
if event.get("candidate_sha256") != candidate["candidate_sha256"]:
raise MirrorError("CANDIDATE_HASH_MISMATCH")
@ -218,7 +222,8 @@ def review(event: dict[str, Any], state: Path, kind: str) -> dict[str, Any]:
raise MirrorError("MOTHER_ACCEPT_REQUIRED_BEFORE_TEAM_REVIEW")
receipt = {
"schema": f"guanghu.lighthouse-persona-skill-{kind}-review/v1",
"reviewer_kind": "TCS_MOTHER" if kind == "mother" else "GUANGHU_HUMAN_TEAM",
"reviewer_kind": expected_kind,
"reviewer_authority_root": expected_root,
"reviewer_id": reviewer_id,
"module_id": module_id,
"contribution_id": contribution_id,
@ -226,6 +231,7 @@ def review(event: dict[str, Any], state: Path, kind: str) -> dict[str, Any]:
"decision": decision,
"reason_code": event.get("reason_code", "NONE"),
"external_effect": "NONE",
"authentication_state": "LOCAL_STRUCTURAL_ASSERTION_PENDING_SIGNED_PUBLICATION_GATE",
}
atomic_json(state / "reviews" / kind / f"{contribution_id}.json", receipt)
return receipt

View file

@ -25,6 +25,10 @@ def contribution(**overrides):
return value
def review_event(item, kind, reviewer):
return {"module_id":item["module_id"], "contribution_id":item["contribution_id"], "candidate_sha256":item["candidate_sha256"], "decision":"ACCEPT", "reviewer_id":reviewer, "reviewer_kind":"TCS_MOTHER" if kind == "mother" else "GUANGHU_HUMAN_TEAM", "reviewer_authority_root":"TCS-MOTHER-LPM-0001" if kind == "mother" else "TCS-0002∞"}
class MirrorAgentTest(unittest.TestCase):
def test_architecture_mirror_allowlists_and_has_no_private_path(self):
with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as temp:
@ -59,11 +63,10 @@ class MirrorAgentTest(unittest.TestCase):
with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as temp:
state = Path(temp)
item = M.prepare_contribution(contribution(), state)
base = {"module_id":item["module_id"],"contribution_id":item["contribution_id"],"candidate_sha256":item["candidate_sha256"],"decision":"ACCEPT"}
with self.assertRaisesRegex(M.MirrorError, "MOTHER_ACCEPT"):
M.review({**base,"reviewer_id":"TEAM-1"}, state, "team")
M.review({**base,"reviewer_id":"MOTHER-1"}, state, "mother")
M.review({**base,"reviewer_id":"TEAM-1"}, state, "team")
M.review(review_event(item, "team", "TEAM-1"), state, "team")
M.review(review_event(item, "mother", "MOTHER-1"), state, "mother")
M.review(review_event(item, "team", "TEAM-1"), state, "team")
record = M.register(item["module_id"], item["contribution_id"], state)
self.assertEqual(record["state"], "ARRIVAL_REGISTERED_LOCAL_NOT_PUBLISHED")
self.assertFalse(record["runtime_enabled"])
@ -72,18 +75,26 @@ class MirrorAgentTest(unittest.TestCase):
with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as temp:
state = Path(temp)
item = M.prepare_contribution(contribution(), state)
base = {"module_id":item["module_id"],"contribution_id":item["contribution_id"],"candidate_sha256":item["candidate_sha256"],"decision":"ACCEPT","reviewer_id":"SAME"}
M.review(base, state, "mother")
M.review(base, state, "team")
M.review(review_event(item, "mother", "SAME"), state, "mother")
M.review(review_event(item, "team", "SAME"), state, "team")
with self.assertRaisesRegex(M.MirrorError, "INDEPENDENT_REVIEWERS"):
M.register(item["module_id"], item["contribution_id"], state)
def test_review_command_cannot_change_registered_authority_root(self):
with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as temp:
state = Path(temp)
item = M.prepare_contribution(contribution(), state)
event = review_event(item, "mother", "MOTHER-1")
event["reviewer_authority_root"] = "TCS-0002∞"
with self.assertRaisesRegex(M.MirrorError, "AUTHORITY_ROOT"):
M.review(event, state, "mother")
def test_hash_drift_and_replay_rejected(self):
with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as temp:
state = Path(temp)
item = M.prepare_contribution(contribution(), state)
with self.assertRaisesRegex(M.MirrorError, "CANDIDATE_HASH"):
M.review({"module_id":item["module_id"],"contribution_id":item["contribution_id"],"candidate_sha256":"0"*64,"decision":"ACCEPT","reviewer_id":"M"}, state, "mother")
M.review({**review_event(item, "mother", "M"), "candidate_sha256":"0"*64}, state, "mother")
with self.assertRaisesRegex(M.MirrorError, "REPLAY"):
M.prepare_contribution(contribution(summary="changed"), state)